Dual CPU Database Server Comparison
by Johan De Gelas on December 2, 2004 12:11 AM EST- Posted in
- IT Computing
Benchmark Configuration
To ensure that our databases work stably and reliably, we followed the guidelines of SUSE and IBM. For example, DB2 is only certified to run on the SLES versions of SUSE Linux; you cannot run it on any Linux distribution. We also used the MySQL version (3.23.52) that came with the SUSE SLES8 CD's, which was certified to work on our OS.Software
IBM DB2 Enterprise Server Edition 8.1.3 (DB2ESE), 32 bit and 64 bitMySQL 3.23.52, 32 bit and 64 bit
SUSE SLES 8 (SUSE Entreprise Edition) SP3, Linux kernel 2.4.21, 32 bit and 64 bit
Hardware
We'll discuss the different tested servers in more detail below. Here is the list of the different configurations:Intel Server 1: Dual Intel Nocona 3.6 GHz 1 MB L2-cache, 800 MHz FSB - Lindenhurst Chipset
Intel® Server Board SE7520AF2
2 GB (4x512 MB) Micron Registered DDR-II PC2-3200R, 400 MHz CAS 3, ECC enabled
NIC: Dual Intel® PRO/1000 Server NIC (Intel® 82546GB controller)
Intel Server 2: Dual Xeon DP 3.06 GHz 1 MB L3-cache, Dual Xeon 3.2 GHz 2MB L3-cache, Dual Xeon 3.2 GHz
Intel SE7505VB2 board - Dual DDR266
2 GB (4x512 MB) Crucial PC2100R - 250033R, 266 MHz CAS 2.5 (2.5-3-3-6)
NIC: 1 Gb Intel RC82540EM - Intel E1000 driver.
Opteron Server 1: SUN V20z Dual AMD Opteron 248 (2.2 GHz)
Newisys Khepri based board
2 GB: 4x512 MB Infineon PC2700R - 250033R (2.5-3-3-6)
OR 2 GB: 4x512 MB Mushkin PC3200R-232 (2-3-2-6)
NIC: Broadcom 5703, bcm5700 driver
Opteron Server 2: HP DL-145
HP motherboard
2 GB: 4x512 MB Infineon PC2700R - 250033R (2.5-3-3-6)
or 2 GB: 4x512 MB Mushkin PC3200R-232 (2-3-2-6)
NIC: Broadcom 5703, bcm5700 driver
Opteron Server 3: Tyan Thunder K8W (S2885) based
Tyan K8W S2885
2 GB: 4x512 MB Infineon PC2700R - 250033R (2.5-3-3-6)
or 2 GB: 4x 12 MB Mushkin PC3200R-232 (2-3-2-6)
NIC: Broadcom 5703, bcm5700 driver
Opteron Server 4: HP DL-585
HP custom designed motherboard
4 GB: 8x512 MB Infineon PC2700R - 250033R (2.5-3-3-6)
NIC: Broadcom 5703, bcm5700 driver
Opteron Server 5: AMD Quartet: Dual 844, Dual 848, Quad 844 and Quad 848
Quartet motherboard, Zildjian personality board, Tobias backplane board and Rivera power distribution board.
Quad configurations: 4 GB: 8x512 MB infineon PC2700 Registered, ECC enabled
Dual configurations: 2 GB: 4x512 MB infineon PC2700 Registered, ECC enabled
NIC: Broadcom NetExtreme Gigabit
Client Configuration 1: 1x Pentium 4 3.06 GHz HT on - 533 MHz FSB
MSI GNB MAX FISR (E7205)
2x512 MB Crucial PC2100R - 250033R (2-2-2-6)
NIC: 1 GB Intel RC82546EB - Intel E1000 driver
Shared Components
1 Seagate Cheetah 36 GB - 15000 rpm - 320 MB/s
Maxtor 120 GB DiamondMax Plus 9 (7200 RPM, ATA-100/133, 8 MB cache)
46 Comments
View All Comments
smn198 - Thursday, December 2, 2004 - link
Would love to see how MS SQL performs in similar tests.mrVW - Thursday, December 2, 2004 - link
This test seems foolish to me. A 1GB database? All of that fits in ram.A database server is all about being the most reliable form of STORAGE, not some worthless repeat queries that you should cache anyway.
Transactions, logging... I mean how realistic is it to have a 1GB of database on a system with 4GB of RAM and expensive DB2 software.
A real e-commerce site likeMWave, NewEgg, Crucial could have 20GB per year! Names, addresses, order detail, customer support history, etc.
Once you get over a certain size, a database is all about disk (putting logging on one disk indepdent of the daata, etc.). The indexes do the main searching work.
This whole test seems geared to be CPU focused, but only a hardware hacker would apply software in such a crazy way.
mrdudesir - Thursday, December 2, 2004 - link
man i would love to have one of those systems. Great job on the review you guys, its good to know that there are places where you can still get great independent analysis.Zac42 - Thursday, December 2, 2004 - link
mmmmmmm Quad Opterons......Snoop - Thursday, December 2, 2004 - link
Great readksherman - Thursday, December 2, 2004 - link
is that pic from the 'lab'? (the one on pg 1)